Mystery Box of Damaged Jigsaw Puzzles

Mystery Box of Damaged Jigsaw Puzzles

9 reviews
Regular price£9.00
# of Puzzles
  • Order today, ships tomorrow
  • Free Puzzle Piece Replacements
  • In stock, ready to ship
  • Inventory on the way
📦 Free US Shipping on orders over $75

For a limited time only, purchase a mystery box of jigsaw puzzles that have light damage to the product box. The jigsaw puzzle inside is untouched and in perfect condition. Enjoy savings of up to 75% off - only $10 per puzzle! Your mystery box may or may not include:

  • Puzzles with piece counts ranging from 100-2,000 pieces
  • Brands included are Puzzlefolk, Puzzledly, Piecework, Galison, Fred & Friends, Water & Wines, Jiggy, Cloudberries, eeBoo, Minty Fizz, Talking Tables, University Games, Stellar Factory and more!
  • Puzzle product box that has small dents, creases, and/or tears

We are unable to accommodate special requests due to large demand. 

•Free Ground Shipping available for all US domestic orders over $75

•US orders under $75, we offer discounted shipping rates from UPS and USPS - based on order weight and shipping speed

•Expedited shipping options are now available at checkout

•Orders ship from Charlotte, NC

•Orders placed before noon EST (Monday-Saturday) will ship same day

•International Shipping Available (Duties, taxes and shipping calculated at checkout)

In 2019, four puzzle enthusiasts had an idea. After discovering what was a shared frustration in their inability to find a puzzle they could not wait to tackle, these four women started tossing around the idea of creating their own puzzles. These women, who also happen to be related, not only love to puzzle, but they love a challenge — especially competing against each other. The idea evolved while on a family vacation, where of course a puzzle was in tow, and the initial framework of what was soon to become — Puzzledly was developed. They each envisioned vibrant, artful puzzles of the highest quality. They imagined reaching for the untapped puzzle potential that was just not available in the market at that time. They pictured other families sharing a similar bonding experience when building together, complete with colorful stories and belly laughs.

Over the span of 6 months, they searched high and low for the perfect images, eye-catching shades, and stylish designs for their jigsaw puzzles. When their first shipment arrived they could not wait to break their first set of 5 puzzles open. 3 puzzlers set to work in North Carolina while the fourth eagerly awaited for hers to be shipped to New Jersey. They each set right to work. Texts were sent, calls were made, and photos of their progress were sent. None were disappointed. The puzzles were perfect! They were stunning, creative and fun! They were challenging, yet achievable creations that fed their competitive nature and stimulated their minds. 

These four puzzle enthusiasts had an idea …. and Puzzledly was born. Ready to join them?


Customer Reviews
4.2 Based on 9 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
United States United States

Fun surprise!

I loved getting my mystery puzzle! It was fun to get something I wouldn't normally pick out for myself, and the box damage was pretty minimal. It's great that they've decided to sell these "less-than-perfect" puzzles at a discount - it's a win-win for Puzzledly and me!

United States United States


Thought it was going to be a box of puzzles. It was just one puzzle the sells new for 12.50 currently. Not much fun or savings. Probably won’t do again in the future.

Laura J.
United States United States

I misunderstood

I received my order, which was one puzzle. The puzzle looks perfectly fine, great pic and no damage. I guess my confusion was that it sounded like there were multiple puzzles in the box rather than just one. Looks great though!

Melinda C.
United States United States

My Third Mystery Box Order is the Best Yet!

Signing up for text notifications for this Mystery Box is dangerous (but still highly recommended). This was my third mystery box order, and Puzzledly kindly reached out to ask what I received in my first two orders, so they could do their best to not send me repeat puzzles. I love everything I received, and did not own any of the puzzles yet. Some brands I received this time include Cavallini, Puzzlefolk, Soonness, Puzzledly, Whiskey River Soap Co, Top Trenz, Eeboo and Galison. Looking forward to completing all of them!

Melinda C.
United States United States

Another Fun Assortment

After loving my first mystery box collection where I regretted not buying more, I immediately bought 10 the second I saw more go up (via Instagram ads). I'm not as in love with this second collection, but only one puzzle is a repeat of one I already had, so I can't complain. I'll still continue to buy more! This time around I received 5 brands I've tried before, but 4/5 were puzzles I didn't have yet, 1 was a brand I have, but haven't tried yet (****** mystery puzzle), and 4 were new brands to me. One of these brands I didn't particularly care for the style of illustration (Cupcake Totally Chill by Top Trenz), but the quality was great! I'm most excited to try Puzzlefolk for the first time! I took two that I completed (Top Trenz and Werkshoppe) to my local library's swap shelf, and they were quickly taken.

A Puzzledly Customer
Stacie G.
United States United States

Mystery Box Review

I guess I thought there were be numerous puzzles in the shipment instead of just one 1000 piece puzzle. I love the puzzle I received and the box wasn’t damaged at all, but for $10 plus $7 shipping, I expected to be getting a “deal” not just one puzzle.

Melinda C.
United States United States

Fantastic Assortment

I am so pleased with the selection of puzzles I received from the damaged box sale. I ordered 8, and still wish I ordered more. I received puzzles from Cloudberries, Happy Place, Trevell, Water & Wines, Jeneral Collective, and Puzzedly. I only received one puzzle I've completed before, and 4 of 6 brands I hadn't tried before. I will absolutely purchase any future mystery box collections, and I'm adding more puzzles from each of these brands to my wishlist.

Beth Z.
United States United States

Love my puzzles!

I ordered a batch of their mystery puzzles that puzzledly was selling at a reduced rate due to light damage to the boxes. The boxes were hardly damaged at all and I could barely tell! I love all of them. My only problem was that delivery required my signature to drop the packages which was super inconvenient since I live in an apartment building. Other than that, puzzledly was great and I will probably order from them again!

Recently viewed