Mystery Damaged Jigsaw Puzzle

Shipping was so fast for the West Coast. I love getting these because I don’t mind minor box damage. The puzzles inside are perfectly fine. My only gripe is that these sell out very quickly after getting the text notification.

I have ordered these mystery damaged jigsaw puzzles a few times now, and I’ve never been disappointed. I’ve received small and big puzzles, brands I’ve never tried before, some of my most favorite puzzles I’ve done, and it’s SO much fun. The damage to the boxes has always been minimal with no issues with the actual puzzle. It’s definitely worth the money and the fun of the surprise!

Great Damaged puzzle! I could barely notice any cosmetic damage. I will buy again! Also, such a good deal!

I am now on my third mystery box. My heart always races when I get the notification that the deal is available. I had my poor mum individually gift wrap each puzzle from my last box so I could be even more excited at the discovery. I have gotten a couple of repeats but this has been a great opportunity to try out brands and high quality puzzles I could not otherwise afford

Always a nice surprise. The puzzle boxes have barely any damage. Puzzles pieces are perfect.

Incredible picks!

This is such a great deal for a box that is minimally damaged. Delivery drivers damage boxes more than these are sometimes.

I'm relatively new to puzzling and have been trying a bunch of brands, so this was perfect for me. It seems like the Puzzledly staff puts a lot of care into their selections (or maybe it's a very happy coincidence): I received brands from my wishlist that I hadn't yet tried, a new-to-me brand with an image that's right up my alley, and a new release from an absolute favorite, one corner of the box just barely scratched. As previous reviewers have said, the damage is minimal if at all (e.g. a scrunched corner, a slight tear in the plastic wrapping) and well worth the price!

This was so good, I got a proud puzzle. I was hype. Thank you.

I got 3 1000 piece puzzles from different companies. One box had creases/dent, but thing major. Would probably buy again if I'm fast enough. My only issue was with shipping, but that was on USPS.
When looking at the current prices on Google, it was a steal. I purchased 3 for $30 USD total. All in, the prices found ranged $55-$60.

I was very happy to find out that a mystery damaged jigsaw was hardly damaged in my eyes and i was very happy with what was shipped to me.

Love the mystery box puzzles. Such a great deal for a new puzzle with little damage to the box.

Such a great deal, love the puzzles!

This is such a deal and completely worth the price.

I love this deal. Its fun getting a random puzzle at a great price. All the boxes I received were hardly damaged.

I received one puzzle I already had and one puzzle I didn’t want, but everything else was FANTASTIC. I’m especially excited about trying three new brands. As always, I recommend buying in bundles to increase the chances you get a puzzle you love.

As a repeat customer of the Mystery Damaged Puzzle Box, my anticipation never seems to wane with each order, and once again, I was absolutely not disappointed! There's something uniquely exhilarating about placing the order and waiting for your treasure to be delivered. The anticipation of not knowing what I’m about to dive into adds a layer of excitement that’s hard to find in ordinary purchases.
I continue to be impressed by the variety and the condition of the puzzles. Unpacking each puzzle brings its own joy and surprises.

For anyone who relishes puzzles and the thrill of a good mystery, this is an absolute must-have. Already looking forward to my next box!

I have never been disappointed in any of the discount damages I’ve ordered. Greatest deal in the puzzleverse.

I am always shocked by the quality of the puzzles I get from this deal! Most of the time I can hardly tell there is any damage to the boxes. Has been a fun way to try puzzles I normally wouldn't select. Sometimes I have a hard time deciding what to do next and love the randomness of not knowing what is coming!

My favorite mystery box Included a Happily puzzle and this one included 2! 😱 I received 2 puzzles I already had and 2 I don’t want and will immediately swap, but the Happily Puzzles and some others by Piecely, Puzzlefolk, and Eeboo make this a box I still love!

I normally buy boxes of 10+ to get free shipping and increase my chances of getting a few puzzles I love. This time I only ordered three to use a Shop app credit and I was so happy with the three I received. Maybe I didn’t need to be buying 11 at a time all this time. 😆 I received Cavallini Flowers, Ridley’s 50 Must Read Books, and Lantern Press Leave No Trace. Such great art on all of them!

I took a chance and bought 2 mystery boxes and was pleasantly surprised by the selection! both puzzles were definitely my style and taste. thank you!

After ordering a mystery box of 12 puzzles and only really wanting to keep 1, I ordered more when they became available to make myself feel better. It was a great decision because I loved this box a lot more. It included Cloudberries, Cavallini, Lantern Press, and a Reverie I’ve wanted (Stories in the Stars). Highly recommended!

This was my least favorite mystery box I’ve purchased. Out of the 12 puzzles I ordered I immediately swapped 8 without doing them. A couple were ones I had owned and already completely, but most were ones I just didn’t care to keep or complete. It was heavy on gradient style puzzles when I like detailed illustrations. I still recommend this great deal though!

I’ve ordered so many mystery boxes from Puzzledly and this has been my favorite yet because it includes the exact puzzle I’ve been wanting - Stamped by Happily Puzzles. I think it’s the only puzzle I won’t ever swap because I love stationery!

My order of 12 puzzles included two puzzles I already own but they are good brands and I will swap them. My box also included a couple brands I haven’t owned yet (Blue Lobster, Mon Joli), one brand I own but haven’t tried (Solu) and familiar brands I enjoy like Galison and 1 Canoe 2.

If you aren’t signed up for restock notifications, go sign up! I recommend buying more than 1 puzzle to increase the odds you’ll get a puzzle you love.

The box is dented? No problem. Box scratched? No big deal. Puzzle in a bag?
Wonderful!

I was trying hard to not buy new puzzles recently, but I have to make an exception for Puzzledly. I ordered a box of 10 mystery puzzles, and loved 8/10 of them. I immediately gave away two because I already had one, and didn't want the other, but I'm so excited about the other 8 puzzles. They included Cavallini, Clementoni, Cloudberries, Editions Sulo, Lantern Press, MasterPieces, Paperhood, and Puzzle Culture. Four of those brands are new to me and I can't wait to try them!

Such a great value!!