Gifting has never been easier
Perfect if you're short on time or are unable to deliver your gift yourself. Enter your message and select when to send it.
We will send you an email to reset your password.
Buy 3 or more puzzles, get 20% off your order! Discount is automatically applied at checkout. Cannot be combined with other promos.
We will send you an email to reset your password.
📦 Free USA Shipping on orders $85+ 📦 International Shipping Options Available
Shipping options with delivery date estimates available at checkout.
Creep it real and keep it cute. The Creep It Real 250-Piece Puzzle Set serves up just the right mix of spooky and sweet, featuring three delightfully haunted designs that celebrate cozy Halloween vibes. Think pumpkins, ghosts, spell books, and shelfie-worthy fall flair, each puzzle finished with UV clear holographic foil that shimmers when the light hits just right.
Each mini puzzle assembles to 11" x 14", making them perfect for a relaxed puzzling session, a spooky-season tradition, or a thoughtful gift for your favorite fall fanatic. Packaged together in a premium tray tied with ribbon, this set is ready to charm straight out of the box.
Adding product to your cart
Look at this packaging. Look at that beautiful velvet ribbon that ties in a bow at the front. How am I supposed to gift this when it's so pretty? Luckily for me, I bought this set for myself!
You can wiggle the boxes out without untying the ribbon. The puzzle pieces are bagged in sealed baggies, and there is a mini poster provided. I love how the bottom of each box has the company and artist printed, so these can all be gift these individually if you'd like.
EDIT:
I have to redact a star, because...nope, nope, nope! The holographic film is a big NO. It covers the whole puzzle for all three designs, and if you're familiar with holo effects (e.g. trading cards) the way light diffracts made all the colors blend into a homogenous blob of either white or black, eliminating all details. The only way to see the clear image is from an angle where the light is not bouncing off it. This was especially bad for the lightest design, "Creep It Real". It made the whole experience much more frustrating than it should have been. I would have much rather preferred holo in select areas, or none at all. The holo does photograph nicely for the dark colors, but it only photographs nicely and doesn't show up in person lol.
Most Liked to Least Liked: Trick or Treat > Break Out the Ghost Stories, It's Spooky Season > Creep it Real
To be fair, a lot of it could have been user error. I puzzle in the evening after work, which means less natural light, especially now that the sun sets earlier. I also don't have the best lighting, and I decided to do them all without looking at the image.
So, it's my previous review still stands, but you can bet I'll never buy a fully holographic puzzle again.
orders of $85+
View our policy here.
Be the first to know about new puzzle releases & restocks.
By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time.
Gifting has never been easier
Perfect if you're short on time or are unable to deliver your gift yourself. Enter your message and select when to send it.